Abstract
We examine how a startup's strategic positioning, including whether it frames its technology and market approach as disruptive or collaborative, affects talent acquisition in new ventures. Although prior research has examined how disruptive positioning influences investors, its impact on prospective employees remains less well understood. We conduct two preregistered field experiments with an early-stage climate-technology startup in India, randomly assigning prospective software engineers to receive disruptive, collaborative, or, in the second experiment, neutral positioning language while holding all other job and firm attributes constant. Across both experiments, positioning affected candidates' perceptions of the opportunity. In Field Experiment 1, when candidates encountered positioning early in the application process, disruptive positioning reduced application completion by 6 percentage points and, conditional on completion, increased compensation demands by nearly 5% relative to collaborative positioning. In Field Experiment 2, where treatment was introduced later, completion rates did not differ significantly, yet candidates exposed to disruptive positioning demanded 9% higher total compensation than those exposed to collaborative positioning. Benchmarking against a neutral control suggests that this gap was driven primarily by collaborative positioning lowering compensation demands relative to baseline expectations. Follow-up evidence from interviews and a survey experiment suggests that disruptive positioning increased perceptions of technological novelty, specialized skill requirements, and effort demands. Consistent with this mechanism, the compensation gap was concentrated among more experienced and higher-earning candidates. Overall, our findings demonstrate that strategic positioning affects candidates' willingness to engage with startup employment, impacting the cost of attracting talent.