When the Jerome A. Chazen Institute for Global Business opened at Columbia Business School in 1991, globalization seemed to be the future, bringing more trade, deeper capital flows, and efficient supply chains. Today, according to Glenn Hubbard, Dean Emeritus and Russell L. Carson Professor of Finance and Economics, the world has entered an era of “globalization under constraints.”
The institute marked its 35th anniversary with a panel of three speakers: Hubbard, the institute’s director; Professor Abby Joseph Cohen, a former chief investment strategist at Goldman Sachs; and Xavier Rolet (MBA ’84), former CEO of the London Stock Exchange Group. Brooke Masters, U.S. managing editor of the Financial Times, moderated.
While their economic outlooks differed at times, the panelists agreed on one point: Volatility is here to stay.
A calm economy is the exception
Cohen argued that the stability of the past few decades was the real anomaly. For 25 to 30 years before the recent economic turbulence, inflation stayed under control and interest rates barely moved
“One of the reasons the volatility that we now see feels so uncomfortable is that so many decision makers forgot that it could be coming,” she said. Even excluding food and energy, she added, core inflation runs at 3.5% or higher, well above the Fed’s 2% target. Decisions by the current administration, such as ill-conceived tariff policies, are contributing to the volatility.
Concurring, Hubbard pointed to a built-in tension in the Treasury market, the largest bond market in the world, among an ever-expanding supply of Treasuries; tight balance sheet rules for commercial banks; and a calm bond market. “You can only have two of the three,” he said.
On energy, Hubbard noted, China and the West drew down their reserves to soften the recent oil shock, but “that of course can’t be done forever.” His conclusion: “We’re at the beginning, not the end of the volatility.”
For business leaders, he advised scenario planning, so they can decide in advance how to respond if a key choke point or policy shift hits their business.
Basic research drives future growth
Cohen warned that cuts to scientific research threaten the United States’ long-term edge. Chinese government spending on scientific research and development rose tenfold from a small base 15 to 20 years ago, while in the same period the U.S. slipped.
The U.S. decline predates the current administration, Cohen noted. But the administration’s latest budget cuts NASA’s research funding by 25% and sharply reduces support for the National Institutes of Health and the National Science Foundation.
That matters, she explained, because “companies don’t do basic research,” instead prioritizing commercial impact. If the U.S. does not fund emerging fields such as quantum computing and biotechnology now, she warned, “other nations can take the leadership on it.”
Hubbard agreed, noting that economists, himself included, have estimated such high social returns to government-funded basic research that it “comes close to paying for itself.”
Rolet also agreed that the U.S. “has substantially diminished its appetite for fundamental research in a number of areas.” In quantum, however, he saw a different picture. Pointing to several well-funded federal quantum programs, he said, “The argument could be made that the U.S. is catching up.”
Immigration as a growth strategy
Hubbard called demographic decline “the biggest question people aren’t talking about.” His answer: “High-skilled immigration is our ticket out if we want to take it.”
Cohen noted that the U.S. birth rate has slowed for decades, and immigration has, in the past, offset it. Before the pandemic, she said, immigrants accounted for roughly 60% of the annual increase in the labor force. They also make up a significant portion of working PhDs in medicine and technology in the U.S. Two-year visa renewals for PhD candidates, and uncertainty over whether a partner can get a visa, make the country a less attractive bargain for that talent.
“We are creating impediments to our own economic growth,” she said.
AI’s promise — and its friction
Hubbard sees “enormous productivity growth potential” in AI. He called it the latest general purpose technology, in a lineage that includes the internal combustion engine and the internet. He does not expect mass unemployment. A job, he explained, is really a bundle of many tasks, and AI disrupts some far more easily than others.
The change will come in what jobs look like, though, he acknowledged, and that change may “feel just as jarring.”
Cohen added that “the friction will be very painful for many people.” She pointed to opinion surveys showing sharply rising anxiety about AI among young adults, a group that she said had been the most enthusiastic just a year earlier.
Regulation is another open question. After all, Congress, she noted, “still has not figured out how to regulate the internet.”
History suggests the adjustment could take time. After the industrial upheaval of the early 20th century, Cohen said, “it took about 20 years for the average family, the average household, to be okay.” She hopes K-12 education keeps pace so teachers can prepare students for new kinds of work.
The panel ended on an optimistic note. Asked what is going right for the U.S., all three panelists pointed to innovation, backed by deep capital markets and by universities that, in Cohen’s words, are “without parallel anywhere else in the world.”